Showing posts with label carbon sequestration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label carbon sequestration. Show all posts

Saturday, October 9, 2010

More on Carbon Sequestration


Brother Dave followed up on comments regarding carbon sequestration in forests in my previous post with the following erudite comments:

Dean,

Per your request I looked at your latest posting. I have always been
of the view (without data of course) that a mature forest (read "old
growth") is probably not sequestering much or any carbon on an
incremental basis. Admittedly there is a huge amount of carbon locked
up in those big trees, but that is not really the policy issue. The
analysis should always be at the margin. How much annual incremental
carbon is sequestered (through tree growth) or released (through tree
death or harvest and resulting decomposition) is the question the
analysis should be focused on. I think the greenies tend to confuse
the debate by focusing on a static analysis rather than a dynamic one.

It sounds like the site you were visiting had slow growth rates
resulting from 100 year old logging practices and resulting site index
damage. OK, not much incremental sequestration and if there are some
really old trees around which are falling down it could be negative.
As an alternative think back to the trip we took to Mt. St. Helens a
few years back. Remember the Weyco noble fir forest that had been
planted up there. Those trees looked like they were growing so fast
that you could hear them grow if you were quiet enough at night. The
incremental carbon sequestration on that site had to be quite large
compared to the site you were looking at and even bigger than the
adjoining federal lands where no replacement timber had been planted.

This tends to lead to an argument that we should liquidate old growth
and plant new trees which we pick for rapid growth and then apply a
variety of growth generating silvicultural practices. Makes sense in
the abstract, but I am not sure it is quite that simple. First you
have to consider what happens to the old growth forest you liquidate.
About the best you can do with that is convert it to building products
and put it into structures which will defer the carbon release for
another 100 years or so. As to the slash and residuals fro the
manufacturing process the preferred prescription seems to be to use it
for energy generation. Those of us in my industry and the biofuels
industry like to argue that any carbon released in that process is
irrelevant because of the replacement sequestration occurring in the
tree farm. Fair enough, so long as you don't count the tree farm
twice that way, once for the benefit of the guy who owns it and once
for benefit of the guy who is burning the slash and residuals.

A better solution is to maximize the recovery from the log/tree into
building materials and other useful products which do not release the
carbon for an extended period. Is there a process to turn slash into
a solid object such as a plastic? If so how much energy does that
process consume. This gets really complicated. Another question that
occurs to me is the rate at which growing trees sequester carbon. I
can just about guarantee that if you plotted annual sequestration
versus tree age, it would not be a straight line. It would start out
very low (because the tree is very small) and end very low (because
the tree is not growing). Again, however, no data. However, all this
means is that the replacement of old growth with a new tree farm does
not give you a year one payback. It will take time before the
incremental sequestration of the tree farm catches up and "covers" the
carbon released as a result of the harvest. All nice in theory but
pretty much worthless speculation without real data. This is the kind
of question where the assumptions swallow the answer and site
differences will yield significant variances in outcome.

Oh well. Way to complicated for this mere finance lawyer. I have to
go and prepare to teach a class to a bunch of third year law students
on deal making.


DGG

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Carbon Sequestration Ad Nauseum


From Scientific American Carbon-Offset Cowboys Let Their Grass Grow - January 2009

http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=carbon-cowboys

"\Rangeland sequestration projects have generated only about 200,000 credits but are on the cusp of a major boom. The rangelands of the American West naturally absorb about 190 million tons of carbon dioxide a year. That’s about what 40 coal-fired power plants emit, but there’s still plenty of room for improvement. Through its Rangelands Soil Carbon Management Offsets Program, the exchange offers a financial incentive for ranchers to increase the amount of carbon dioxide that is absorbed by their lands. Sun Ranch was the first to qualify."


"Soil Sequestration Grass absorbs carbon dioxide the same way trees do, but on a smaller scale. Through photosynthesis, each plant takes carbon from the atmosphere and uses it to build more plant matter. When grass dies or trees are cut down, that carbon is released back into the atmosphere. But grass plants also release carbon out of their root tips to fungi in the soil, says Stephen Porder, who teaches biogeochemistry at Brown University. “When those roots die or the fungi die, they’re eaten by some microbe or worm, and a portion of that carbon gets stabilized,” he explains. “It gets stuck onto a clay mineral or a particle and stays in the soil.”"

OK, a tiny tiny portion of the carbon from dead plant material gets incorporated in the cells of the critter (fungi, microbe, etc.) which metabolizes the grass and its roots. The vast majority however is released immediately into the atmosphere. The net actual sequestration is highly unlikely to merit the amount of money our government environment activists would like to award to the "ranchers" who will take this land out of production. If I could get paid for growing cheat grass, rabbit brush and sage I would invest in all the high desert I could lay my hands on.

Carbon sequestration makes a little (very little) sense when considering forest ecosystems, it makes no sense at all when looking at range lands. It is worse than a simple waste of money to invest in this so called technology. Spending dollars to in a what amounts to an environmental scam not only steals from tax payers but does less than nothing to reverse the increase in CO2 in the atmosphere. Cap and Trade schemes will do absolutely nothing to reverse the process of climate change. They will provide cash flow for those savvy enough to play the game.

This is simple chemistry and biology. It is no mystery how photosynthesis and respiration work in the exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide. Let's stop the wishful thinking and get on with the task of finding alternatives to fossil fuels. Allowing range lands and farm lands to lay fallow, and leaving forest management to the tender mercies of insects and disease will not get the job done. Come on people! Cowboys grow cows and manage their lands. They don't just find ways to scam the taxpayer for funds so that they sit on the deck drinking martinis and grooming their poodles.

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Carbon Sequestration





Please allow me to get up in your grill and debunk one of the favored shibboleths of the environmentalist or "Green" movement. In a recent editorial in the "Oregonian" on the subject of sustainability and City government the author stated "As we all learned in kindergarten, planting trees creates oxygen, captures carbon, and eases global warming".

Let me state at the outset that even if the above statement were true it is highly unlikely that I would have learned it in kindergarten (1952-1953). I am quite sure that I did not learn that trees produce oxygen and store carbon at the knee of Mrs. Gross my kindergarten teacher in Reno, Nevada. More importantly it must be noted that the simple rules of biology, chemistry, and mathematics render the whole idea of "carbon sequestration" to the to the arena of "not so much". Here's why:

Carbon: The subject here is biomass, not just trees. We are talking about all green plants. It is true that the process of photosynthesis results in the intake of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and it's subsequent conversion to carbon based cells making up leaves, stems, twigs, reproductive bits, etc.

Oxygen: It is also true that the above mentioned photosynthetic process results in the release of oxygen as the CO2 is converted in the process. OK, carbon in, oxygen out... So far so good.


Death: If no biomass ever died our atmosphere would quickly become so oxygen rich that the first spark would ignite all organic material on the planet in a really big firestorm. Fortunately plants (also unfortunately, humans) die. In fact plants are constantly shedding vast amounts of dead material in the form of leaves, needles stems, and of course overall death of the organism. So lets, look again at the flow of oxygen and carbon.

When plant material dies, or is burned the result is the same - Oxidization. That is when a leaf falls to the earth it is gradually consumed by microorganisms which consume the plant material. In the digestive process the process of metabolic respiration takes place converting the food to energy. This results in the consumption of atmospheric oxygen, and the release of our old friend carbon dioxide. In other words, all the carbon sequestered by living plants is eventually returned to the atmosphere either by respiration or fire. All of the oxygen originally released is consumed either by metabolic respiration or fire.

Ah, but what about wood, the alert reader may ask. It is true that wood in service (lumber in your house, furniture, etc.) sequesters carbon for the duration of its existence as wood. Two factors limit the importance of wood as a reservoir of carbon. Firstly if you look at the life cycle of a tree, you will observe that the total production of disposable biomass (leaves, fruit, twigs, etc.) dwarfs the volume of wood in the bole (trunk) of the tree. Hence most of the biomass of trees returns its carbon to the atmosphere on an annual basis. Secondly, when said wood rots, is eaten by termites, or burns, our old friend oxidization returns its carbon back to the atmosphere as CO2. This brings up an interesting question. If all the Oxygen delivered up to the atmosphere is eventually traded for CO2 upon the metabolism or burning of biomass, what then accounts for the free Oxygen in the atmosphere? I believe I have an answer for this question but will leave it up to you to posit your own answers in the comments section to follow.


Please do not assume from my clinical dissection of carbon sequestration that I do not value the "green" world. Deforestation of large tracts of land via slash and burn agriculture, reckless harvesting, wildfire etc. certainly has detrimental environmental consequences. In addition to the production of oxygen via photosynthesis, trees are prodigious movers of water. The process of transpiration of water provides the majority of water feeding the tropical storms of the mid latitudes. This is one of the reasons that massive deforestation leads to desertification. Forests and grasslands protect, even create, watersheds. But, please do not buy into the carbon sequestration, carbon offset, carbon management politics being heaped upon us by the biologically illiterate activists. If your goal is to put carbon "in jail" via planting of trees, please consider that the net effect of these efforts will be at best negligible. There are a lot better reasons to plant trees than this.

In conclusion. I am haunted by the fact that I must be wrong about all this. How else could our local Land Rover dealer in good faith make the following offer. Upon purchase of a gas swilling carbon emitting Land Rover automobile the dealer will donate sufficient funds to an environmental activist group who will in turn plant sufficient trees to offset the production of carbon by your car for 50 years! Please fair reader tell me how this is not pure balderdash, hokum, or at least a bonehead error on the part of the Land Rover company. Surely, we can just plant a few trees and save the climate, the planet, and relieve us of this unrelenting guilt...